Here in Westchester, NY we don’t have a shortage of Ice Cream Shops! But with so many choices, you might be wondering to yourself, “where in Westchester should I go?” Well, look no further because here you can find the scoop on some of the best ice cream shops in Westchester!
Whether you enjoy your ice cream, soft served, with sprinkles or without, this list has something for everyone!
I hope this post encourages you to try something new while supporting a local business! And if you are looking for a restaurant to dine at while watching the sunset, make sure to check out “ 10 Waterfront Restaurants In Westchester.”
Ice Cream Social ( White Plains)
Newest Ice Cream Shop in Westchester. Owned by 2 High School Friends that grew up in White plains!
What they serve; Classic Ice Cream Flavors, Vegan Ice Cream Flavors, Ice Cream Cakes, Pints, Coffee and tea.
Special kind of flavors: They serve Affogato which is ice cream topped with a shot of espresso. Unicorn Cake
What else To Know : Outdoor seating and parking in front of the shop is available.
Longford’s (Rye)
Local chain producing premium ice cream in small batches, since 1992.
What they serve: Ice cream, sorbet, frozen yogurt, custom cakes, donut sundaes, sundae bars
What else To Know: Additional locations in Stamford, CT & Larchmont
Yum Ice Cream (New Rochelle)
According to wikipedia “Roll up ice cream” or “stir-fried ice cream” was a new concept that originated in Thailand in 2009 and has been in the United States by 2015. This shop in New Rochelle rolls up the ice cream flavor of your liking, then you choose your topping and finish it with sauce.
What they serve: Rolled up ice cream, Bubble tea, smoothies (dairy free options available)
Special kind of flavors: Honey dew, Thai Tea, Taro
What else To Know: Delivery through, Uber eats, Doordash and GrubHub
Bona Bona Ice Cream (Port Chester)
Want to make your ice cream bonafide? Bona Bona Ice cream has you covered with their signature embellishment which is torched Italian meringue.
What they serve: Ice Cream Sandwiches, warm desserts, milkshakes, cakes, boozy milkshakes. Vegan options available & they also serve wine and beer!
Special kind of flavors: Italian Rainbow Cookie, Frosted Animal Cracker, Nutella S’mores just to name a few.
What else To Know: They can bring the ice cream to you via catering through their ice truck or cart (indoors & outdoors). They have a private room for parties, where it rains sparkles! They offer nationwide shipping and have a second location in Delray Beach Market in Delray, Florida.
Penny Lick (Hastings)
Simple and quality ingredients are what you can find in every lick of Penny Lick Ice Cream. All creams are peanut and tree nut free!
What they serve: Ice cream, Milkshakes, Ice cream cakes
Special kind of flavors: Lavender Truffle, Earl Grey, White Bourbon Caramel just to name a few.
What else To Know: You can book a cart for your special event or host a party at the shop.
Bigfoot Creamery (Ossining)
Enjoy Ice cream with a view at Bigfoot Creamery, located at the Ossining waterfront. This kiosk style ice cream shop serves handmade local ice cream.
What they serve: Ice cream & fun toppings like glitter sprinkles and dinosaur sprinkles.
Special kind of flavors: Seasonal flavors for summer, autumn and winter.
What else To Know: Flavors change daily, check out their instagram account to stay on top of the latest menu. Kids park right next to the shop, card only.
The Hudson Creamery (Peekskill)
What they serve: Soft serve ice cream, sundaes, milkshakes, cakes, pies, ice cream bars, cookie sandwiches and pints.
Special kind of flavors: Apricot Orange Blossom, Strawberry Balsamic plus seasonal and vegan options available.
What else To Know: They host birthday parties, ice carts for private parties & painting socials.
Paleteria La Michoacana (Yonkers)
If you are looking for adventure for the taste buds check out Paleteria La Michoacana. It’s a mexican ice shop with an overwhelming selection of ice pops (Paletas in Spanish) made with real fruits.
What they serve: Ice pops, (dairy free options available) ice cream, milkshakes, and natural fruit juices (agua frescas in Spanish). They also have classic Mexican snacks.
Special kind of flavors: Passion fruit, Soursop & Sorrel Mango with chili, etc.
What else To Know: It can be difficult to find parking, cash only. Second location in Mt. Vernon
The Blue Pig (Croton-On-Hudson)
Cozy and cute place with a constant rotation of different ice cream flavors.
What they serve: Ice cream, milk shakes, sundaes sorbet, baked goods, ice cream cake. Pints and Vegan options are available.
What else To Know: All flavors are available while supplies last!
BlueBird Ice Cream (Cross River)
Small batch and homemade ice cream with premium Lactose- and gluten-free flavors are also offered. Ice cream menu includes 20 to 25 rotating flavors:
What they serve: Ice cream, stumptown coffee & baked goods.
What else To Know: Mother son business, original ice cream was opened in and still is in Settle.
